Vacation rentals in Old Tappan

We had a perfect long weekend at Steven's cottage. It is bigger than it looks in the photos and was immaculately clean when we arrived. Steven was extremely responsive to all our questions and needs. The place is incredibly peaceful, a 2 min walk from the lake, on a private road where Steven owns all three houses. It was so relaxing and rejuvenating to spend time at this oasis with my partner and our best friends. There's a lot to love, but the best part is that the house comes with a private deck and dock, and unlimited access to various boats, to make your lake weekend whatever you want it to be. We loved that we could take our dogs to play fetch off the dock and not worry about getting in anyone's way or having to share any space. It was a great stay and we hope to go back!

We had a very nice stay, the house is like the pictures and everything is clean and neat. Jolanta is a great host very friendly and helped us with everything.

Excellent stay! Hosts were responsive and very helpful. The house is absolutely beautiful, the pictures do not do it justice. The location is perfect and we had a wonderful time. The house was very clean and had beautiful decor. Highly recommend! Five stars one of my favorite and I will definitely be back. Thank you to Susan and Zoe for a wonderful stay.

We had a wonderful long weekend! The house was perfect! It was very clean, cozy and we loved the cabin feel inside. We also enjoyed playing pool and air hockey. It is super close to the lake and several delicious restaurants. My kids and dogs also had a great time. Adriana was quick to respond when I had questions. I highly recommend this house!!

Nice cozy cottage one block from the beach.. spent many hours walking the beach and found many beautiful shells and sea glass on our walks. Cozy cottage perfect for us and our dog in a quiet and beautiful neighborhood.

Had an amazing stay at this beautiful property. It was spacious, clean, and had everything we needed. The host was responsive and super helpful with everything. The views and location were truly incredible. I recommend this house to anyone who is looking to stay in this area.

Beautiful property and wonderful hosts who were so accommodating as to drive out to fix the internet for the one member of our group who needed to unfortunately work during our stay. Accommodations were basic and comfortable, which were expected and perfect for our group. We were there on the first chilly weekend of fall and able to spend both nights around the cozy wood stove during the evening and the dock during the day. The lakefront community is beautiful and I hope we can return with our dogs during the summer to take advantage of swimming and kayaking next year.

I had the pleasure of staying at this wonderful home in Pennsylvania, and it truly exceeded my expectations. The house was cozy and clean. The attention to detail was evident from the moment we arrived, with thoughtful touches and a well-equipped kitchen. The location was also perfect, peaceful, yet close enough to local attractions for easy access. Our host was incredibly responsive and helpful, providing us with clear instructions and even some local recommendations, which made the stay even more enjoyable. Overall, I highly recommend this property for anyone looking for a weekend. Would definitely stay here again!

The house was full of delightful character and the peaceful surroundings felt magical. We felt right at home and enjoyed our family gatherings there. Thank you, Joe, for opening your lovely home to us!