Vacation rentals in Otterbein

We loved our stay at Kaloni's place. Her barndominium is just close enough to Georgetown to feel connected, but just far away enough to feel private. Kaloni is a responsive and welcoming host and we felt well taken care of! We'll probably stay here again in the future!

We enjoyed our stay. The place was spotless and clean. It was in a great location to drive to local restaurants and get downtown. Would stay here again!

This cabin and the area surrounding was even more beautiful than the photos. It overlooks a huge canyon that was fun to explore. The cabin itself was great and had all the amenities we needed to cook great meals. Was very impressed by the cooking utensils in the cabin, the view, Anna’s responsiveness, and the overall “bang for your buck” when it came to this property. Our group had a fantastic time. Lots of spaces in and on the property to relax and enjoy nature. Would highly recommend if looking to stay in this area.

From the moment I inquired about the property Michael went above and beyond! The best communication and accommodating host I have ever dealt with. The home was clean, cozy and had everything you could possibly need. Extra supplies, toiletries, snacks upon arrival! Five stars without a doubt! Hands down did not disappoint! I appreciated his willingness to work around my daughter’s soccer schedule. We felt at home from the moment we arrived. If we are ever in this area again I will without a doubt stay here! So many options as well restaurants, coffee, grocery store, you name it! Our personal favorite restaurant was Grindstone on the Monon! Again, Michael hands down went above and beyond for my family!

Quiet, easy to find, and, yet, close to restaurants. Horses were nice to visit with and trails gave something extra to do. Janet was there to meet us and answered any questions.

Extremely helpful due to the situation on why we needed such a big house. House was clean, kept all the guests comfortable and able to stay busy with darts, pool table, and hot tub. Host always responded in a reasonable time.

This home was absolutely ideal for our trip to Indianapolis. It came fully stocked with essentials like towels, shampoo, conditioner, and body wash—a thoughtful touch that made packing much easier. The kitchen was impressively equipped with everything we needed, including utensils, pots, pans, and even a griddle. When I reached out to the host upon arrival, she responded promptly and was incredibly helpful. I wholeheartedly recommend this home for anyone planning a visit to Indianapolis!

Josh and Nicole were fantastic hosts! Their place was clean and exactly as pictured. The hot tub was our main reason for selecting this property. The hot tub was well maintained and easy to access. No complaints! We will definitely plan to stay again for our next trip on the area.

Our stay was very nice. It was easy to get into Lafayette and to Perdue. Parking was easy and they accommodated me dropping a few things off earlier than appointed check in. There weren’t any paper towels or regular coffee but everything else was great and well appointed. Plenty of room for a small group to gather.