Fish Lake fishing vacation rentals

Amazing spot right on the water. Rental was as described. Peaceful and beautiful area.

Melissa Joy's place is so peaceful and cozy. Our family of 10 adults, 2 toddlers, and an infant were very comfortable. The little ones had plenty of room to play and the adults had great seating with a beautiful view of the lake. The kitchen was perfectly stocked to host our family Thanksgiving dinner. We had such a great time and we plan to return for the summertime!

We had a wonderful time celebrating my brother's engagement and catching up with old friends! It was super peaceful but also had plenty of room to host a party and have a good time. We would 100% come back. My only warning to those coming here is to bring throw blankets if you are used to always having some.

Great staying here again. Even got an Irish win this time. Lake so serene with my morning coffee.

Awesome location and awesome home, would love to come back! Made us feel very welcome!

This was a great house for my family weekend get together. Beautifully decorated, large bedrooms and plenty of room to hang out. View of the lake was gorgeous even in the winter. Would like to try it again in the summer when we can enjoy all the amenities.

Came with another couple of friends for the weekend, this was a very nice, relaxing place to come back to and cook nice meals after going out to the local nature preserves.

My family has been here before and it was during the summer and we loved it sooo much that we came back but this time it’s during spring, we definitely prefer going during the summer but we love this place so much!!! My kids love it ❤️ we loved using the grill and the paddle boats. Would definitely suggest it for families!

I had a wonderful stay at this Airbnb with a couple of friends. The accommodations were excellent, and we truly enjoyed our time there. We didn't want to leave. Overall, it was a fantastic experience and I highly recommend this house.

We enjoyed our time at the lake. Amazing and serene home. So wonderful to have my dogs with me and they loved the yard. Anna is helpful and responsive. Looking forward to our next visit this summer and fall.

We had a wonderful time and spent a lot of time on the fantastic back porch. This is how every Airbnb should be! The beds, bedding, baths and kitchen were excellent.

Leah was a phenomenal host, very responsive and fast with her replies to my questions. The place was super comfortable and welcoming. It was peaceful and quiet just as advertised. Had a wonderful stay!

Beautiful space for a large family gathering. The house is lovely and the big windows overlooking the lake were fantastic. Beware, if you claim the master bedroom, the en suite shower is so awesome, everyone will be trekking in to use the six nozzle shower :-) Joe was great to communicate with. We highly recommend this place!

So glad I stumbled upon Steph's Ice House listing. Had a peaceful, almost secluded stay yet close to the many Shipshewana attractions. Impeccably clean and decorated, with modern amenities which would be fantastic for an extended stay. Steph sent a greeting message immediately after my booking and followed up with detailed instructions and area tips. Was pleasantly surprised with doughnuts and popcorn when I arrived, a very nice touch. Looking forward to booking with her again!

Our hosts were amazing! They took us in with a warm welcome and support after we were in immediate need of housing. The amenities were excellent from coffee to toothbrushes, dishes and linens. They had everything we needed to walk in and get a good night's sleep. We enjoyed the view, sunshine and time together with our family.

If you’re searching for the perfect lake house to accommodate the whole family, look no further than this gem on Big Fish Lake. From the moment we arrived, it was clear that this house was exactly what we had been hoping for. This lake house on Big Fish Lake was perfect for our family getaway. Nestled in a quiet neighborhood, it offered a peaceful escape with ample space for everyone. The house was comfortable and well-equipped, and the pier was a fantastic spot for fishing and enjoying the lake. A standout feature was the screened-in porch, ideal for morning coffee or evening relaxation. Overall, this property exceeded our expectations with its blend of comfort, convenience, and scenic beauty. A delightful extra was the water toys that came included with the rental. Highly recommended for a relaxing family retreat!

My friends and I had a wonderful stay! The house is super cute and is close to the beach, shops, restaurants , the grocery store, and more! We were out of a few things but they responded immediately and dropped it off asap! We would definitely come back! Thank you!

Was an absolutely relaxing stay. It was exactly what my husband and I were looking for. An extended weekend away with a bunch of things around us to do. It had a little bit of everything around us, including privacy. It was fantastic.

Great location in adorable Grand Beach! A true old school Beach house perfect for our extended family. Just steps to the beach and a short drive to New Buffalo. We loved it and will be back. Chris was super responsive when we had questions and an issue with the door lock.

I cannot say enough about how clean the house was. Wonderful space for everyone. Kitchen table was large enough for my group to play games at and the basement space was large enough for everyone too! If we are back in the area we would stay here again!

Our stay at Pam’s was so very nice Comfortable bed. Having washer/dryer Ami’s a plus. The lake view is BEAUTIFUL! Pam made everything easy and communicated quickly and well. We will be back. Did I mention, the view was Great?!

Clean house and will definitely book again for our needs. Very comfortable with everything.

Beautiful house, very well thought out for guests. Host and Co-Host were absolutely wonderful through the whole process. Lots to do in the area. Would highly recommend!

very fun relaxing experience, stayed in the back cabin. great time