Lake side cottage rentals in Conneaut Lake

This was my third time staying at Cheryl’s Airbnb—if that’s any indication of how much I love it! It’s truly one of the warmest, most inviting places I’ve stayed. Tucked in a quiet neighborhood with shops and restaurants nearby (including a great bagel shop within walking distance), it’s both convenient and peaceful. The beds are super cozy, the home is spotless, and the bathroom is warm with great ventilation. The kitchen has everything you need—from coffee to cooking utensils—and the living room is full of thoughtful touches like throw blankets and small amenities that show how much care Cheryl puts into the space. The lake is just a short walk away and stunning in every season. Cheryl is kind, quick to respond, and genuinely welcoming. I’ll absolutely be back again!

Corey’s place was one of our best ABNB stays ever. As ABNB hosts, ourselves, we greatly appreciated the perfectly clean space, friendly and helpful communications, as well as the convenient location and modern amenities. Everything necessary for a fabulous stay is provided and we’re happy to recommend Corey’s place to anyone considering a stay.

Mark is very responsive to the texts and any questions about the local area. He is very friendly and laid back. Off the main road, the lake scenes from front balcony are super nice. There is a local dock for fishing, swimming, or launching a canoe. Some good restaurants and a meat-seafood market are nearby for grilling. He supplies everything, so just bring the family or friends to start your relaxing stay. The house was clean and well stocked. This was our second stay.

Wendy's Lakehouse was exactly what my husband and I needed for our mini-retreat after our daughter's wedding. We were mentally, physically, and emotionally exhausted when we arrived; but after a couple of days of complete quiet and privacy in the house, walking and laying on the private beach, listening to the water, watching the sunsets, and basking in the fresh Lake Erie breezes: we felt restored and refreshed. The only thing that disappointed us was that we couldn't stay longer... life rolls on! 😅 Within hours of our arrival we were making plans to return- next time with our 4 sons- as soon as possible! We even were dreaming about bringing future grandkids in years to come! 🥰 Thank you, Wendy, for providing this peaceful retreat!

We've stayed here many times. The convenient location is close to everything. Steph is a wonderful host.

I cannot say enough good things about this Air BnB. It was the perfect location for us to be close to family. The house was well-kept, very clean and we felt right at home. Again, this is a terrific location and we cannot wait to stay there again in the future. The kitchen had everything you could need, furniture and beds we’re comfortable and it has central air!!! Love this place and it is on our shortlist for future visits to Sandy Lake. Thank you for sharing your home with us!

This house it great! It’s super cute, very comfortable, a great place to stay in and do nothing or to go visit wineries. The buzz are extremely comfortable and everything was nice and clean. The host Even left us a bottle of wine and snacks. They couldn’t make it any easier.

Donald’s house was the perfect location for our winter weekend getaway in GOTL! The house is even more beautiful in person, and it is kept very neat and tidy! Donald was extremely responsive any time I reached out! He is an excellent house with a gorgeous home in the heart of Geneva! I can’t wait to stay again!👌🏻❤️

The airbnb was clean and beautiful. It looked exactly like the photos and had a ton of space. The co-host Will was always reachable and responded timely with questions, etc.

Great place to stay. Very clean and welcoming. I would definitely go back again.

We enjoyed our 3 night getaway! The private beach was incredible. We enjoyed a peaceful time on the lake with our two dogs. - 85 inch TV in the family room for watching football - gas grill and blackstone for the barbecue - fire pit - beach supplies including 2 kayaks and life vests - comfortable master suite with jacuzzi tub - game room with pool table So much fun and many possibilities!

Quiet neighborhood, very nice hot tub, and very clean rooms. Would recommend this place to anyone looking to stay in Erie.

What a beautiful home, very clean, well laid out and plenty of room for all of us to stay and relax for a long weekend to attend our daughters wedding. Host was VERY responsive and very friendly. Could not have asked for a better place to stay during this wonderful event. Loved seeing the rabbits playing in the yard at night and the chipmunks playing on the patio every morning.

It was cozy and private with a beautiful view of the lake. Would definitely love to stay again sometime!

Nice clean lil spot it was perfect for fishing we tagged out every day it is a good base camp for are fishing trip would rent it again

Another peaceful stay at a home with all the amenities. Robin is a great host!

First off, Rikki is an awesome host! Extremely friendly, outgoing and genuine. I had zero issues with the cottage. It is really nice, clean and very cozy. She gets you started with lots of food products, coffee and the little things most don't do. We stayed in touch during my extended stay and she was always available with instructions for things that I needed help on. She never made me feel like I was a bother. I would stay here again and again, and I most certainly will in the future. Not only is the cottage wonderful, Rikki made the stay even more enjoyable!

This was our second stay at the cottage, and it was just as great as the first. Luckily for us the weather was great this year, so we got to use the sun porch every morning for breakfast. We also like that even though there were 8 adults in the cottage it doesn't feel cramped. It is stocked with everything you would need to make a meal.... although you really should be eating at one of the restaurants on the strip! Sean was easy to get ahold of and responded very quickly, which we appreciate! Can't wait to stay again next year!

Unbelievably clean! Great location!

5th time staying here to visit our daughter at Edinboro University. We feel right at home each time we go. Cozy, comfortable cottage with all the amenities we need for a great stay! Karen is an excellent host! We will be back👍

This house was the perfect getaway! The location was close to town and the highway but in a nice quiet neighborhood. The space and amenities were exactly as listed and all the kid friendly additions at the house were great! The hosts were very friendly and responsive. Would definitely recommend and would stay here again!

We came into town for a wedding at the Lodge, which was SO close to this Airbnb. The Airbnb inside was beautiful and perfectly cozy for what we needed. The outside was a bit confusing, but once I read the directions William sent a few times, I figured it out. The neighbor was very nice and chatty when we arrived, and even put out a candle for us so there would be less bugs when we got back from the rehearsal dinner. Overall, it's a very cute little place to stay, super close to the heart of Geneva, easy to find lots to do from there! I would 100% stay there again.

This little cottage was adorable! It’s within 15-20 minutes of Erie. We went to splash lagoon, the mall and to the kids museum. There’s an AWESOME playground within walking distance of the cottage. Several great restaurants/diners within a mile of the cottage. Host was very accommodating and responsive. Overall the place is a gem! We will definitely be staying again.

This lovely cottage close to Edinboro Lake was well-appointed and very cozy to stay in. Everything you could need (or maybe forgot to pack) was available for use in this beautiful cottage. Would highly recommend to any couple/family looking for a quiet place to stay instead of a noisy hotel- much more privacy. Thank you Mark and Karin for sharing your wonderful cottage- we made memories to last for our family ❤️!